A Simple Analysis of Taxation in Indonesia and Futures Trading Tax

_{image source}

Hello LeoFinance, I'm interested in analyzing taxation in Indonesia. I've compiled this article based on my knowledge and various sources I've read.

Taxation is one of the main sources of revenue for the Indonesian state. With taxes, the government can build roads, schools, hospitals, and fund many other social programs. Therefore, the tax system should be fair, clear, and not burdensome for the public or businesses.

However, in practice, the tax system in Indonesia still faces many challenges. Some feel the rates are high, while others are confused because the regulations often change or are not uniform across all sectors. One interesting area to discuss is taxation on futures trading, often referred to as futures contracts.

What is Futures Trading?

Futures trading is the transaction of buying and selling an asset in the future at a predetermined price. For example, someone might buy a coffee or gold futures contract, hoping the price will rise later.

This activity is often conducted on futures exchanges such as the Jakarta Futures Exchange (JFX) and is supervised by Bappebti. In addition to seeking profits, futures trading is also used by business actors to hedge against losses when market prices fluctuate.

How Is Tax Imposed on Futures Trading?

The Indonesian government has stipulated that income from futures trading transactions is subject to a final Income Tax (PPh) of 2.5% of the initial margin. The initial margin is the deposit deposited by the trader to open a trading position. This regulation is stipulated in Government Regulation Number 17 of 2009 and further explained by the Directorate General of Taxes.

This is final, meaning the tax is deducted immediately and is not combined with other income in the annual tax report. From the government's perspective, this system is practical because it is easy to control and generates immediate revenue.

_{image source}

Problems and Challenges Faced

Although the tax system is in place, many market players consider the 2.5% rate to be too high. In comparison, the tax rate on stock transactions in the capital market is much lower. This makes some investors and traders reluctant to transact in the futures market.

In addition, there are still several other obstacles:

• There are no clear regulations regarding losses. If a trader experiences a loss, there is no regulation on how to deduct it from taxes.
• Lack of legal certainty. Many market players feel there is no comprehensive technical guidance from the government.
• There is no distinction between hedgers and speculators. However, their goals are different; for example, hedgers want to protect prices, while speculators seek profit.
• Global competitiveness remains low. Other countries have lower tariffs and more flexible systems, allowing investors to flee abroad.

_{image source}

Analysis and Opinion

In my opinion, the tax system for futures trading in Indonesia needs improvement to support the growth of a healthy and attractive financial market for investors. Some steps that could be considered include:

• Lowering the final tax rate from 2.5% to a lower rate or a gradual rate based on transaction volume.
• Providing compensation for losses to be fairer for market players who lose.
• Separating the treatment of hedgers and speculators, as their goals differ.
• Strengthening coordination between institutions, such as Bappebti, the Financial Services Authority (OJK), and the Directorate General of Taxes (DGT), to ensure regulations are more synchronized and easier to understand.
• Increasing education and transparency so that taxpayers understand their obligations and are not afraid to transact in the futures market.

With these changes, it is hoped that taxes can remain a source of state revenue without stifling domestic investment and trade.

Conclusion

In general, futures trading taxes in Indonesia already have a clear legal basis, but their implementation still requires improvement. If tax policies are made fairer and more flexible, the futures market will grow rapidly, increasing liquidity, and increasing state revenue. The government simply needs to adjust regulations to suit global market dynamics and the needs of domestic businesses.

Official Reference Sources:

• Directorate General of Taxes of the Republic of Indonesia –
• Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Indonesia
• Government Regulation Number 17 of 2009 concerning Income Tax on Income from Futures Transactions
• University of Indonesia academic study on futures transaction tax

This concludes this post. We hope it's helpful.
Regards
@ponpase

Posted Using